ReactionLouisiana

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Monday, September 9, 2013

Two-state solution unlikely anytime soon

Posted on 8:30 AM by Unknown
By Frank Moraes

I'm very interested in the Israel-Palestine conflict, but it is such a mess that I rarely hazard an opinion about it. So I was very interested to see an article this morning in Al Jazeera America, Analysis: Israelis Not Ready for Two-State Solution. It is by an Israeli journalist, Dimi Reider, and it is calm—and sad.

His analysis is that the Israeli people are not ready for a two state solution to the conflict. They claim to be for one, but this is mostly just theoretical well wishing. When asked about things like land swaps, which would be necessary for any deal, they disagree. What's more, public opinion goes down the more an actual plan comes into focus. So it really comes down to the fact that the Israeli people would like peace, but they really aren't willing sacrifice anything to get it.

Even worse, Palestinian attacks on Israelis end up hurting the poor almost exclusively, "those who would use public transport and shop in outdoor markets." Thus, the power elite have no reason to want a settlement to the crisis and the poor are angry about the bombings and so become more nationalistic.

The situation on the Palestinian side is far worse. They have largely learned that violence only makes their lives harder. So Palestinian nonviolent protest—never a minor form of political involvement (not that you would know it fromwestern press coverage)—has greatly expanded in recent years. But this puts them in a Catch-22 situation. If they engage in violence, it will make things worse and will not lead to a negotiated settlement. But if they do not engage in violence, there will be no pressure on the Israeli government to do anything and so it will not lead to a negotiated settlement.



The status quo is generally all right with the Israeli people. And so the Israeli government can stand by and allow more and more illegal settlements in Palestinian land—each one of which only makes a final settlement harder. Historically, conflicts like that between Israel and Palestine would have been resolved with a genocide. But with the eyes of the world watching, Israel can't do that. (I'm not suggesting that Israel is especially bad here; they are the more powerful group; I don't think the Palestinians would be any different if theywere the more powerful group.) But it is hard to see the constant trickle of illegal settlements as anything but a slow motion genocide.

Given all the problems, I think a solution to this situation will take outside help. This is one of the great tragedies of the Bush Jr administration. We gave up a great opportunity to push for an end to this conflict. Instead, we invaded Iraq. So in addition to all of the bad consequences of that war, the opportunity costs were probably even worse. I see the Israel-Palestine conflict as a local infection that poisons the politics of the rest of the region. It seemed like Kerry was interested in addressing the problem. But he's shown far more gusto for bombing Syria. I have very little hope for the future when it comes to the whole region, and this Israeli-Palestinian conflict in particular.


(Cross-posted at Frankly Curious.)
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in Middle East | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Reid backs down from compromise of compromise
    By Frank Moraes This is how Democrats work. First they compromise. Then they back off. Then they come back with more compromises. Then they ...
  • Behind the Ad: Mitch and Rand go fishing for votes
    By Richard K. Barry (Another installment in our extensive " Behind the Ad " series.)   Who : The Mitch McConnell Senate campaign...
  • Anathema: Universal (coming soon)
    By Michael J.W. Stickings On September 23, the great post-prog label Kscope is releasing Anathema's Universal , a four-disc set (2 CD,...
  • The stupid party rolls on
    By Mustang Bobby Last winter Louisiana Gov. Bobby Jindal told his fellow Republicans that the GOP has to “stop being the stupid party.” Ap...
  • The mythical political center
    By Frank Moraes Yesterday on the cover of the New York Times , Jonathan Martin wrote one of those stupid Villager articles we all know and d...
  • Echoes of Nam
    By Carl Lemme see….lengthy war, delicate negotiations , frustrated allies …yup! Sounds like Nam all over again! WASHINGTON -- President Obam...
  • Barack Obama, Surveillor-in-Chief
    By Michael J.W. Stickings Barack Obama has done a lot of really good things as president, and I have remained for the most part enthusiastic...
  • Plan B for Plan B
    By Mustang Bobby After several court battles, the Obama administration and the Department of Health and Human Services has dropped their opp...
  • Why poverty happens to good people
    By Carl Lesson to learn -- it’s usually not their fault. Case in point: Donald Cardin became a firefighter at age 20 in Central Falls, R.I.,...
  • Vladimir Putin gives America the finger by giving Edward Snowden a free pass
    By Michael J.W. Stickings Let's not make too much of this. Snowden may very well be in a transit zone at Moscow's Sheremetyevo Airp...

Categories

  • 1984 election (1)
  • 2008 Democratic presidential nomination (1)
  • 2008 election (2)
  • 2012 election (1)
  • 2012 vice-presidential debate (1)
  • 2013 elections (6)
  • 2014 elections (10)
  • 2016 election (2)
  • 2016 elections (1)
  • 2016 Presidential election (1)
  • 2016 Republican presidential nomination (1)
  • 2018 elections (1)
  • 9/11 (1)
  • A..M. Headlines (1)
  • A.M Headlines (4)
  • A.M. Headlines (11)
  • A.M. Headlines (65)
  • A/M. Headlines (1)
  • ABC News (1)
  • abortion (4)
  • ACORN (1)
  • Affordable Care Act (5)
  • Afghan War (1)
  • Afghanistan (2)
  • Al Sharpton (1)
  • AL-1 (1)
  • Alabama (2)
  • Alaska (3)
  • Alison Lundergan Grimes (1)
  • Amazon (1)
  • Andrew Cuomo (1)
  • Andrew Ross Sorkin (1)
  • Andrew Sullivan (1)
  • Anthony Bourdain (1)
  • Anthony Kennedy (2)
  • Anthony Weiner (4)
  • anti-gay bigotry (10)
  • anti-immigrant bigotry (2)
  • anti-Muslim bigotry (4)
  • Antonin Scalia (1)
  • Anwar al-Awlaki (1)
  • archaeology (1)
  • Arkansas (1)
  • arms trade (1)
  • art (1)
  • Associated Press (2)
  • astronomy (2)
  • bankruptcy (1)
  • Barack Obama (38)
  • Barbara Boxer (1)
  • Barbara Buono (1)
  • Behind the Ad (13)
  • Ben Bernanke (1)
  • Benghazi attack (6)
  • Bernie Sanders (1)
  • bigotry (5)
  • biirtherism (1)
  • Bill Clinton (5)
  • Bill Kristol (1)
  • Bill Maher (1)
  • Bill O'Reilly (1)
  • blogging news (1)
  • Bob Dole (1)
  • Bob McDonnell (2)
  • Bob Schieffer (1)
  • Bobby Jindal (1)
  • Bolivia (1)
  • Boston (1)
  • Boston Marathon bombing (3)
  • Bradley Manning (4)
  • Brazil (1)
  • Brit Hume (1)
  • British Monarchy (2)
  • California (5)
  • campaign songs (1)
  • Canada (2)
  • CBS News (1)
  • censorship (1)
  • centrism (1)
  • Charles Pierce (1)
  • childbirth (1)
  • China (1)
  • Chris Christie (2)
  • Chris Hayes (1)
  • Chris Murphy (1)
  • Christianity (5)
  • Christine Quinn (1)
  • Chuck Grassley (1)
  • Chuck Hagel (2)
  • Chuck Schumer (1)
  • CIA (2)
  • Citizens United (1)
  • citizenship (1)
  • civil rights (1)
  • climate change (1)
  • CNN (2)
  • companies (4)
  • comptroller (1)
  • Connecticut school shooting (2)
  • Conor Friedersdorf (2)
  • conservatism (2)
  • conservative media (1)
  • conservatives (12)
  • Cory Booker (1)
  • Craziest Republican of all time (1)
  • Craziest Republican of the Day (2)
  • crime (1)
  • criminal justice (1)
  • criminal law (3)
  • Dan Snyder (1)
  • David Brooks (1)
  • David Cameron (1)
  • DEA (1)
  • Dean Baker (2)
  • Debra Milke (1)
  • debt ceiling (1)
  • Democratic Party (3)
  • Democrats (24)
  • Detroit (1)
  • Deval Patrick (1)
  • Dianne Feinstein (1)
  • Dick Cheney (1)
  • documentaries (1)
  • DOMA (7)
  • domestic surveillance (11)
  • domestic terrorism (1)
  • DREAM Act (2)
  • drone war (3)
  • Dwight Eisenhower (1)
  • Dzhokhar Tsarnaev (2)
  • E.W. Jackson (3)
  • Earth (1)
  • East Germany (1)
  • Ecuador (1)
  • education (1)
  • Edward Murrow (1)
  • Edward Snowden (15)
  • Eliot Spitzer (1)
  • employment (1)
  • energy (2)
  • Enron (1)
  • entitlement programs (1)
  • environmentalism (1)
  • Eric Cantor (2)
  • Eric Garcetti (1)
  • Eric Holder (3)
  • espionage (1)
  • Europe (1)
  • European Union (2)
  • Evo Morales (1)
  • ExxonMobil (1)
  • Face the Nation (1)
  • Family Research Council (1)
  • farming (1)
  • FBI (1)
  • FEMA (1)
  • Fifth Amendment (1)
  • filibuster (3)
  • first amendment (1)
  • FISA (2)
  • fiscal policy (1)
  • Florida (5)
  • food (4)
  • food industry (1)
  • Food Stamps (2)
  • Football (4)
  • foreign aid (1)
  • Fourth Amendment (1)
  • Fourth of July (2)
  • Fox News (7)
  • France (2)
  • Francois Hollande (1)
  • Frank Wolf (1)
  • gay marriage (1)
  • gay rights (3)
  • George W. Bush (2)
  • George Zimmerman (4)
  • Georgia (3)
  • Germany (1)
  • Glenn Beck (1)
  • Glenn Greenwald (8)
  • global warming (1)
  • government shutdown (1)
  • government spending (2)
  • governor (2)
  • Greg Sargent (1)
  • gun control (2)
  • gun laws (1)
  • gun violence (2)
  • guns (1)
  • Harry Reid (5)
  • Harry Truman (1)
  • Hawaii (1)
  • health care (1)
  • health-care reform (1)
  • Henry Kissinger (1)
  • Hillary Clinton (3)
  • Hispanics (1)
  • history (1)
  • hockey (1)
  • holidays (4)
  • homelessness (1)
  • homosexuality (1)
  • House GOP (1)
  • Hurricane Sandy (1)
  • illness (1)
  • immigration (2)
  • immigration reform (1)
  • income inequality (1)
  • inflation (1)
  • Internet (1)
  • Iran (1)
  • Iraq (1)
  • Iraq War (1)
  • Irish Republican Army (1)
  • IRS (4)
  • IRS scandal (1)
  • Israel (3)
  • Israeli-Palestinian conflict (1)
  • Italy (1)
  • James Comey (1)
  • James Inhofe (1)
  • James Risen (1)
  • Janet Yellen (1)
  • Japan (1)
  • Jazz (1)
  • Jeb Bush (1)
  • Jeff Bezos (1)
  • Jeffrey Bezos (1)
  • Jeffrey Toobin (1)
  • Jenny McCarthy (1)
  • Jesus (1)
  • Jim Graves (1)
  • Jo Bonner (1)
  • Joe Biden (3)
  • Joe Lieberman (2)
  • Joe Manchin (1)
  • Joe Scarborough (1)
  • John Boehner (6)
  • John Cornyn (1)
  • John Dean (1)
  • John Kerry (3)
  • John McCain (5)
  • John Roberts (1)
  • Jonathan Bernstein (2)
  • Jonathan Chait (2)
  • Jonathan Karl (1)
  • journalism (2)
  • justice (2)
  • Karl Rove (2)
  • Ken Cuccinelli (5)
  • Kentucky (4)
  • Kurds (1)
  • labor issues (2)
  • Larry Summers (1)
  • Lawrence O'Donnell (1)
  • Liberals (1)
  • Libertarianism (3)
  • libertarians (2)
  • Libya (2)
  • Lisa Murkowski (1)
  • Listening to Now (6)
  • Los Angeles (1)
  • Louie Gohmert (1)
  • magazines (2)
  • Marco Rubio (2)
  • Mark Begich (1)
  • Mark Udall (1)
  • marriage eqaulity (1)
  • marriage equality (2)
  • Mars (1)
  • Martin Luther King Jr. (2)
  • Maryland (1)
  • Massachusetts (6)
  • Matt Taibbi (1)
  • mayoralty (1)
  • McDonald's (1)
  • media (4)
  • Medicare (1)
  • medicine (1)
  • Memorial Day (1)
  • Mexico (1)
  • Michael Bloomberg (1)
  • Michael Hayden (1)
  • Michele Bachmann (3)
  • Michigan (1)
  • Microsoft (1)
  • Middle East (6)
  • Mike Konczal (1)
  • Minnesota (2)
  • Mississippi (1)
  • Missouri (1)
  • Mitch McConnell (5)
  • Mitt Romney (4)
  • Montreal (1)
  • Montreal Canadiens (1)
  • Morning Joe (1)
  • movies (4)
  • MSNBC (3)
  • music (10)
  • Nancy Pelosi (1)
  • NASA (1)
  • natural disasters (2)
  • Nelson Mandela (1)
  • neocons (1)
  • New Hampshire (2)
  • New Jersey (5)
  • New York (2)
  • New York City (6)
  • news media (7)
  • newspapers (2)
  • NFL (1)
  • Nobel Peace Prize (1)
  • North Carolina (1)
  • NRA (1)
  • NSA (17)
  • nuclear power (1)
  • Obama Administration (2)
  • Obama Derangement Syndrome (1)
  • Obama White House (3)
  • Obamacare (7)
  • obiturary (1)
  • Oklahoma (3)
  • On the Hustings (10)
  • Ontario (1)
  • Osama bin Laden (1)
  • P.M. Headlines (7)
  • P.M. Headlines (54)
  • P.M.Headlines (1)
  • Palestine (1)
  • Pat Toomey (1)
  • Patriot Act (1)
  • patriotism (1)
  • Paul Krugman (1)
  • Paul Ryan (1)
  • personal (1)
  • Peter King (2)
  • Photo of the Day (1)
  • Piers Morgan (1)
  • Planned Parenthood (1)
  • poetry (1)
  • police (1)
  • political ads (3)
  • Politico (1)
  • polling (1)
  • polls (6)
  • polygamy (1)
  • Pope Francis (1)
  • Porcupine Tree (1)
  • pornography (1)
  • Portugal (1)
  • Potsdam (1)
  • poverty (3)
  • President Barack Obama (4)
  • President Obama (1)
  • Presidential Campaign Songs (1)
  • privacy (5)
  • Progressive Music Classics (1)
  • Prop 8 (1)
  • race (3)
  • Rachel Maddow (4)
  • racism (8)
  • Rahm Emanuel (1)
  • Ramesh Ponnuru (2)
  • Rand Paul (6)
  • Ray Kelly (1)
  • redistricting (1)
  • Reince Priebus (1)
  • religion (3)
  • reproductive rights (1)
  • Republican hypocrisy (1)
  • Republican Party (9)
  • Republicans (59)
  • Retro Political Ads (1)
  • Reza Aslan (2)
  • Rhode Islands (1)
  • Richard Nixon (3)
  • Rick Santorum (2)
  • Rick Scott (1)
  • Rick Snyder (1)
  • right-wing extremism (1)
  • Robert Reich (1)
  • Robert Rubin (1)
  • Rolling Stone (1)
  • Ron Paul (3)
  • Ronald Reagan (2)
  • Royal Family (1)
  • Rush Limbaugh (1)
  • Russia (7)
  • Ruth Bader Ginsburg (1)
  • same-sex marriage (8)
  • Sarah Palin (3)
  • scandals (7)
  • schools (1)
  • science (4)
  • Scott Walker (1)
  • Sean Hannity (3)
  • Sen. Ted Cruz (1)
  • seniors (1)
  • separation of church and state (1)
  • Sesame Street (1)
  • sex (1)
  • sex scandals (1)
  • sexism (1)
  • Skype (1)
  • slavery (1)
  • soccer (1)
  • Sochi Olympics (1)
  • South Africa (1)
  • Southern Baptist Convention (1)
  • space (1)
  • sports (3)
  • Stand your ground (1)
  • Steve Benen (3)
  • Steve King (3)
  • Steven Wilson (1)
  • Stuart Stevens (1)
  • stupid Republicans (1)
  • Supreme Court (1)
  • surveillance state (5)
  • Susan Rice (1)
  • Syria (10)
  • talk radio (1)
  • Tamerlan Tsarnaev (1)
  • tax policy (1)
  • Tayyip Erdogan (2)
  • Tea Party (5)
  • technology (1)
  • Ted Cruz (2)
  • television (4)
  • Tennessee (3)
  • terrorism (3)
  • Terry McAuliffe (1)
  • Texas (6)
  • The Bible (1)
  • The Doors (1)
  • the economy (2)
  • The New York Times (1)
  • The Reaction (1)
  • The Republican Party (1)
  • The Supreme Court (1)
  • The US Senate (2)
  • The Wall Street Journal (1)
  • The Washington Post (1)
  • theocracy (1)
  • Thomas Menino (1)
  • Tim Geithner (1)
  • Tom Coburn (2)
  • torture (1)
  • Trayvon Martin (4)
  • Treyvon Martin (1)
  • Tucker Carlson (1)
  • Turkey (2)
  • U.S. budget (1)
  • U.S. Congress (3)
  • U.S. Constitution (5)
  • U.S. courts (1)
  • U.S. Department of Homeland Security (1)
  • U.S. economy (1)
  • U.S. federal government (3)
  • U.S. Federal Reserve (2)
  • U.S. foreign policy (5)
  • U.S. House of Representatives (8)
  • U.S. legal system (2)
  • U.S. Marines (1)
  • U.S. military (6)
  • U.S. national security (3)
  • U.S. Postal Service (1)
  • U.S. Senate (19)
  • U.S. Supreme Court (10)
  • U.S. tax code (1)
  • undocumented immigration (2)
  • unemployment (1)
  • United Kingdom (3)
  • United States (1)
  • US House of Representatives (3)
  • US Senate (5)
  • vaccination (1)
  • Vienna Teng (1)
  • Vimeo of the Day (5)
  • Virginia (8)
  • Vladimir Putin (5)
  • voter fraud (1)
  • voter suppression (1)
  • voting rights (3)
  • Wall Street (2)
  • war (1)
  • war on Christmas (1)
  • war on drugs (1)
  • war on terror (5)
  • war on women (1)
  • Watergate (1)
  • weather (1)
  • welfare (1)
  • West Virginia (2)
  • Westboro Baptist Church (1)
  • Winston Churchill (1)
  • women's health (1)
  • World War I (1)
  • Zimmerman trial (3)

Blog Archive

  • ▼  2013 (500)
    • ▼  September (53)
      • P.M. Headlines
      • Thoughts on Syria
      • Reining them in
      • On the Hustings
      • Two-state solution unlikely anytime soon
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Listening to Now: Bruno Mars, your Super Bowl 2014...
      • P.M. Headlines
      • Gov. Christie doesn't understand loyalty
      • On the Hustings
      • President Pete King?
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Listening to Now: Spyro Gyra - "Morning Dance"
      • P.M. Headlines
      • GOP's continued debt ceiling demands
      • On the Hustings
      • Same old pattern on the right
      • Have to believe it was magic
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Syria is an entry to war with Iran
      • On the Hustings
      • It's only money
      • Behind the Ad: Tea Party group attacks Mitch McCon...
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Happy NFL season!
      • P.M. Headlines
      • While denialists double down...
      • On the Hustings
      • Purple haze
      • A.M. Headlines
      • P.M. Headlines
      • Bad choices
      • On the Hustings
      • Cats and dogs, sleeping together!
      • A.M. Headlines
      • P.M. Headlines
      • OK, so you know how you know Syria is probably a m...
      • On the Hustings
      • Sis-boom-bomb
      • We should negotiate to end the Syrian civil war
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Retro Political Ads: Nixon Now (1972)
      • P.M. Headlines
      • Behind the Ad: Special House election in the Alaba...
      • On the Hustings
      • The image Harry Truman wouldn't want you to see
      • A.M. Headlines
      • Listening to Now: Tim Hardin's "Simple Song of Fre...
      • P.M. Headlines
      • Behind the Ad: Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-TN) on why ...
      • On the Hustings
      • Sunday war mongering
      • A.M. Headlines
    • ►  August (79)
    • ►  July (158)
    • ►  June (128)
    • ►  May (82)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile